30% OFF ALL NEW ORDERS!


*See store for details.

Offer valid October, 2024.

HAND-CRAFTED
IN THE HEARTLAND OF AMERICA

When we say “custom-built” we mean it. At Simply Amish, you choose the wood, the stain and every other element that goes into making your selection unique. We don’t start construction until we receive your order. From that point forward, your furniture is tracked by your name, so that each craftsman knows the person they’re building for.

We Create Custom Furniture

Welcome to Simply Amish of Indianapolis — your boutique furniture store where all of our solid wood furniture is 100% American Made specifically for you. Our Craftsman take such pride in their work that they even go so far as to sign your unique hard wood furniture. Our flagship store has been part of the Indianapolis community since 1994. We design and manufacture every style of furniture you can think of, including a wide selection of upholstered furniture from Norwalk, Elran, and Charleston Forge, and if we do not have what you are looking for, we would be thrilled to design it — just for you.


Let's Work Together

Corporate Website

Spectacular Surface Treatments

Olde World Aging, Rough Sawn, Hand-Scraping, and more!

Our craftsmen create an aged surface that will arouse your senses, without compromising the structural integrity. Don't worry about that first ding. It's the least we can do.



Browse by Room

We sand and stain every bit of each piece entirely by hand. Our solid drawers extend fully, close softly, and are hand finished with dovetail joints in both the front and the back — so they will work and look the same generations from now. Our tables are sealed on the bottom to prevent warping, and like a work of art, every builder signs whatever he has crafted.

At Simply Amish, quality is first and foremost. We know that you will love Simply Amish’s fine, solid–wood furniture as much as we do once you bring it into your home.

Browse All



Browse by Item

Meet our Team

At Simply Amish of Castleton, we pride ourselves on providing an exceptional shopping experience from start to finish. And that begins with our team of committed and very talented sales associates and designers. Stop in and find out for yourself what sets us apart and makes us the most unique shopping experience in Indianapolis. We look forward to meeting you!

Julie

Julie Brogden

Store Manager

Julie has 19+ years of retail sales and management experience. She is passionate about cultivating a unique customer experience and prides herself on her service skills. “Everyday is a new day" is her main philosophy and this helps to keep innovation and the main goals forefront, despite ever changing environments in the industry.

Julie Brogden

Store Manager

Jill

Jill Ulmer Warren

Design Consultant

Jill Ulmer Warren has been a Design Consultant for Simply Amish Furniture for 16 years.

"What an awesome job I have. I make new friends every day, helping them create their own family heirloom and I get to be a part of it! I do not sell, I assist in their decisions! How blessed is that?"

Jill Ulmer Warren

Design Consultant

Susan

Susan Lowder

Design Consultant

Susan has an unwavering passion for interior design and a natural flair for building connections. She loves transforming spaces into personalized works of art by collaborating with each client to achieve their desired outcome.

Susan Lowder

Design Consultant

Ari

Ari Morgan

Design Consultant

Ari has lived in the Indianapolis area for 20 years and was an Resident Advisor at Vincennes University where he studied Interior Design. He likes connecting with people and has a passion for creating comfortable, inviting and beautiful spaces to make memories in.

Ari Morgan

Design Consultant

Nataly

Jessica Dixon

Design Consultant

Jessica brings 4 years of full-service interior design experience and a degree from Ball State University to every project. Mixing creativity with expertise, she knows how to ask all the right questions about your space. Let’s ensure the products you’re interested in fit seamlessly and flow harmoniously in your room with the rest of the elements. Together, we can create spaces that truly reflect your style and personality!

Jessica Dixon

Design Consultant

Inspiration

Inspire Me! Check out our fabulous Makeovers, Recipes, Furniture and Design Trends, Entertaining Tips and all things we absolutely Love, right here!

Image
What a difference drapery makes

No matter your style for home décor, window treatments are often overlooked.
Read More

Image
The Perfect Modern Farmhouse

Lately, we’ve been hearing a lot about the design trend, “Modern Farmhouse” but “Modern Farmhouse” is not a trend, it’s timeless.
Read More

Image
Outdoor Living Spaces

Indoor-outdoor relationships are important to any home design.
Read More

Image
The Art of the "Vintage Glamper"

What exactly is a vintage glamper you may ask? A vintage glamper is what I refer to as, the Best Thing Ever! However, it is also what my husband Jay refers to as his wife’s worst idea to date.
Read More

Image
Every Home Tells a Story: Furniture Customization

One of the current dominating trends in home decor is customization. The new wave of furniture and furniture design is based on the premise that every home has a personality and no two homes need be the same.
Read More



OUR HAPPY CLIENTS

I had a GREAT experience at the Simply Amish store in Castleton. The employees answered all of my questions (I had a LOT of questions) and showed me tons of furniture and samples and even offered me refreshments when I mentioned I was hungry. We are furnishing almost our entire home with pieces from Simply Amish and I can't wait! Next time I'm in town, I will definitely be stopping in! Thank you Simply Amish of Castleton!

- Eva Brent -

I was thrilled with the customer service. Jill was so knowledgeable and patient and helped us select the perfect table. HIGH quality products. Delivery was excellent as well.

- Susan Miller -

Great store and quality furniture. So happy we stopped in today. They have earned our business. Thank you for being gracious, helpful, and allowing us to browse without hassle. What a great experience.

- Kenneth Coe -

Great product....wonderful sales people.

- Todd Pollock -

Extremely high quality products. Beautiful pieces...(Good cookies too).

- Dennis Nicholas -

Thanks Jill for helping make our purchase an easy experience. Great customer service.

- Randy King -

Love them! They make the best stuff and it lasts.

- Surakit Angsuwan -

Great products, nice people.

- Kyle Doles -

Contact Info

  • Address

    4505 East 82nd Street, Indianapolis, IN 46250

  • Phone

    317.579.9490

  • Store Hours:

    10:00 AM – 7:00 PM  Monday—Saturday
    12:00 PM – 5:00 PM  Sunday

  • Subscribe to our Email List

    Subscribe

  • Walk Through Our Store

    Walk Through

Our Location

Send Message

Your message was sent successfully.

Sorry!Something Went Wrong.